Woman holding sweater, wearing diamond engagement ring and wedding band, plus additional diamond bands on other hand |Amidon Jewelers  Engagement FAQs

Engagement Ring FAQs

Choosing an engagement ring is a big decision, and it is natural to have questions. Here are answers to common engagement ring questions from the team at Amidon Jewelers in West Lebanon, NH, serving the Upper Valley and beyond.

Engagement Ring FAQs

Natural and lab-grown diamonds are both real diamonds with the same chemical and physical properties. Natural diamonds form deep within the Earth over billions of years, while lab-grown diamonds are created in a controlled environment. The biggest differences are origin, rarity, and price. Learn more in our lab-grown diamond facts guide, or browse our lab-grown engagement rings.

Yes. Our certified diamonds come with grading reports from respected gemological laboratories such as GIA (Gemological Institute of America) and IGI (International Gemological Institute). These reports detail a diamond's carat weight, cut, color, clarity, and other important characteristics, so you know exactly what you are purchasing. Read more about diamond certification.

The easiest way is to borrow a ring they already wear on the correct finger, or ask a close friend or family member to help. If you're unsure, our team at Amidon Jewelers can help you estimate the size and talk through resizing options after the proposal. If you purchase a ring directly from one of our display cases, the first resizing is complimentary when you bring it back within 30 days.

A bezel setting is among the most secure for everyday wear because metal surrounds the edge of the diamond. Well-made prong settings can also be very secure with proper maintenance. The best choice depends on your lifestyle, diamond shape, and personal style, and our team can help you compare options.

Yes. Amidon Jewelers can help you create a custom engagement ring, whether you want small changes to an existing design or a ring created completely from scratch. You can start online with our ring designer by choosing a setting, a diamond, or our Studio Collection, then work with our team in person at our West Lebanon, NH store. Appointments are recommended for custom design consultations.

Yes. Setting a family diamond in a new engagement ring is a wonderful way to combine sentimental value with your personal style. Bring your stone into our store in West Lebanon, NH, and our team will evaluate it and help you design a setting that honors its history while creating something new.

If you want a custom or special-order ring, start at least two to three months before your planned proposal. We also carry a wide selection of engagement rings in store, so some options may be available sooner. Starting early leaves time to explore styles, select the perfect diamond, and accommodate any customization.

If you spend at least twice as much on a new ring as you spent on your previous ring, we will credit you the full amount you paid the first time. It is a simple way to upgrade your ring as your life and budget grow.

You don't have to, but choosing them together helps ensure they complement each other in style, fit, and comfort. It is especially helpful if you want your wedding band to sit flush against your engagement ring. Browse our wedding bands to see what pairs well.

We recommend a professional cleaning and inspection about every six months. Regular inspections help identify loose stones, worn prongs, and other issues before they become bigger problems. At Amidon Jewelers, cleanings and inspections are complimentary for all of your jewelry, and walk-ins are always welcome at our West Lebanon, NH store.

Yes. Our Assurance Plan offers peace of mind with lifetime maintenance. When you purchase our Lifetime Maintenance Plan, we also gift you the first year of loss and theft coverage at no charge. See our warranty details for more.

Ring Builder FAQs

Creating your ring is easy with just three simple steps. First, select your setting, then choose your center stone, and finally review your completed ring before checkout. You can begin with either the setting or the diamond, whichever you prefer.

Our Diamond Search includes diamonds from our own inventory, along with stones available through trusted partners and suppliers we've worked with for many years. Every diamond is personally reviewed by Amidon before being shipped.

We update our diamond inventory throughout the day, although diamonds from our partners can sell quickly. In the rare event that your selected diamond is no longer available, we'll reach out as soon as possible, typically within one day, to offer similar alternatives or a full refund. Fortunately, nearly all diamonds displayed are available.

Absolutely! You can save your favorite rings and diamonds for later or share a link with someone whose opinion you value.

Of course — it's one of our favorite parts of what we do! Our jewelry specialists are available by phone, text, and chat Monday through Saturday, from 10 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Eastern. Whether you need help understanding the 4Cs, selecting a setting, or finding something within your budget, we're happy to assist. Our goal is to make your online shopping experience feel just as personal as visiting us at Amidon in person.

Yes! Every center diamond featured in our search includes a grading report from an independent gemological laboratory, such as GIA, GCAL, or IGI. You can review the report on the diamond's product page before purchasing, and the original report will be included with your ring. 

Yes, we do! Lab-grown diamonds are chemically, physically & optically identical to earth grown diamonds, offering the same brilliance and hardness as natural diamonds. Each stone is clearly identified as either natural or lab-grown, and lab-grown diamonds are also designated on their grading reports.

Yes. We carefully source our natural diamonds from suppliers who follow the Kimberley Process and the System of Warranties. We do not knowingly purchase or sell diamonds originating from conflict regions.

When a diamond features its own photograph or 360° video, you're viewing the exact stone available for purchase. Some listings may use representative images instead, which are clearly identified. Please keep in mind that diamond colors may appear slightly different depending on your screen. 

Many of our settings can accommodate a diamond or gemstone you already own. We ask that you contact us beforehand so we can inspect your stone and determine the best options. Settings created for customer-provided stones are considered custom pieces (see Custom Pieces below).

Absolutely! We're always happy to help you narrow down your options. Our jewelry experts can put together a selection of diamonds based on your budget and preferences, making the process easier and more enjoyable.

Your ring's total price includes both the setting and the selected center stone. You'll see the combined cost before completing checkout. Because precious metal prices and some diamond costs can fluctuate with the market, your final price is confirmed and locked in once your order is placed.

While we make every effort to maintain accurate pricing, occasional errors may occur. If an item is displayed at an incorrect price, we'll contact you before processing your order. You'll have the option to proceed at the corrected price or cancel your order for a full refund.

We accept major credit cards, cash, and personal checks. Orders paid by personal check will ship once payment has cleared. Third-party financing options may also be available with approved credit, and purchases over $2000 may qualify for 18 months of interest-free financing. Please contact us for additional information.

Yes! Financing options are available for qualified customers. Visit our Financing page or speak with a member of our team to learn more about your options.

Absolutely! We accept eligible fine jewelry toward trade-in credit for your new ring. Please note that once you've taken possession of your new ring, the trade-in becomes final and the standard return policy no longer applies.

Most rings created through our Ring Builder are ready to ship within approximately three to four weeks. Custom designs generally require four to six weeks after the final design has been approved. 

We'll certainly do our best! Let us know your important date when placing your order so we can explore the available options. If you're working with a tight timeline, give us a call, and we'll be happy to discuss what's possible.

All orders are shipped fully insured in discreet packaging without any indication of jewelry on the exterior. An adult signature is required upon delivery, and we are unable to ship to P.O. boxes. Shipping within the United States is complimentary.

Absolutely! We'd love to welcome you into our showroom. Simply select in-store pickup during checkout and bring a valid photo ID when you arrive. We'll also take the time to check the fit and make sure everything looks and feels just right before you leave.

Please reach out to us as soon as possible if you need to make changes or cancel your order. In most cases, adjustments and cancellations can be made before production begins. Once a custom item has entered production, the terms outlined in our Custom Pieces section will apply.

We want you to be completely happy with your purchase. If your ring isn't quite right, stock items may be returned within 15 days of receipt for a refund. Custom pieces have separate return guidelines, which are explained in our Custom Pieces section below.

All returned items must be in their original, unworn condition. Please include the original packaging, diamond grading report, appraisal, and any additional paperwork provided with your purchase. Unfortunately, items showing scratches, damage, or signs of wear cannot be accepted for return.

To begin a return, please contact us by phone or email. Our team will provide instructions for safely shipping your ring with full insurance, or you're welcome to return it directly to our West Lebanon store.

Returns originally paid for by credit card are subject to a processing fee of 3.5% of the purchase amount. This fee does not apply to purchases made by personal check, or to even exchanges.

Once your returned item has been received and inspected, we'll issue a refund to your original payment method, typically within one to two business days. Please keep in mind that your financial institution may require additional time to process and post the refund, which is outside of Amidon Jewelers control.

Certainly! We're happy to help you exchange your ring for another piece within the same 15-day return window. Even exchanges are not subject to a processing fee.

The following purchases are not eligible for return: 

  • Jewelry that has been worn, damaged, resized, engraved, or altered after delivery. 
  • Purchases involving a trade-in once the new item has been received. 
  • Items designated as final sale. 

We understand that some purchases, such as engagement rings bought in advance of a proposal, may require additional time. If you anticipate needing an extended return period, please discuss it with us before purchasing. Any extension must be approved in writing at the time of sale.

A custom piece is any ring specifically created or modified for you. This includes one-of-a-kind designs, alterations to our standard settings, rings made in non-standard sizes or metals, and settings designed to accommodate a customer-provided gemstone.

Unfortunately, custom pieces are non-returnable, and all sales on these items are final. Because each custom piece is thoughtfully designed and created specifically for you, we are unable to accept returns or offer refunds. At Amidon Jewelers, we take great care throughout the design process to ensure your piece meets your expectations. Our team will work closely with you to review and approve all design details before production begins, so you can feel confident in your purchase.

Yes. A deposit is required before we begin production on a custom order. The deposit amount will be confirmed when your order is placed.

Absolutely! Before production begins, you'll have the opportunity to review sketches or CAD renderings of your design. Your written approval is required before we move forward. Please note that changes requested after final approval may result in additional costs or production time.

Engraving is a wonderful way to add a personal touch to your ring, and we offer it complimentary. Please note that engraved rings are not eligible for a refund. If you're undecided, you can always purchase your ring first and add engraving later.

No problem — we're happy to help! You can visit our showroom for a free sizing. If your ring needs to be resized after purchase, we'll provide that service at no charge, provided the design allows for it. Some rings cannot be resized, and we'll explain any sizing restrictions or limitations before your purchase is finalized.

Most rings can be resized, but there are some exceptions. Eternity bands, certain detailed designs, and rings made from alternative metals may not be resizable or may only allow for limited size adjustments.

At Amidon Jewelers, we offer the Montage Platinum Lifetime Assurance Plan, available for purchase, to help protect and maintain your ring for years to come. This plan provides ongoing maintenance and care, helping keep your jewelry in beautiful condition. As our gift to you, we also include the first year of GemShield insurance at no cost, providing coverage for loss and theft. Together, Montage and GemShield offer 360-degree protection, combining everyday jewelry care with insurance coverage for added peace of mind. Our goal is to help you enjoy your ring with confidence for a lifetime!

Absolutely! We provide complimentary jewelry cleaning and inspections. Stop by during our regular business hours, and we'll clean your ring while checking the prongs and setting for security. We recommend having your ring inspected approximately every six months to help keep your diamond safe and secure.

Yes! Our diamond upgrade program allows you to apply the full original purchase price of your diamond toward a new diamond that is at least twice the price of your existing ring.

We highly recommend insuring your ring to protect your investment. Your purchase includes a written appraisal that can be used to obtain coverage through a homeowner's policy, renter's policy, or a specialized jewelry insurance provider.

The Fine Print

Terms of Use. By using our Ring Builder and Diamond Search, you agree to these policies and our Terms of Use. We may revise our policies periodically; however, the terms in effect on the date your order is placed will apply to your purchase.


Accuracy. Diamond specifications are based on reports provided by independent grading laboratories. Metal weights, measurements, and product images are intended to be close approximations. We reserve the right to correct inaccuracies and to limit or cancel orders, including purchases placed at an incorrect price.


Privacy. We respect your privacy and never sell your personal information. Your information is used to process orders, communicate with you about your purchase, and, if you've opted in, share news and special offers. Please review our Privacy Policy for additional details.


Contact Us. Amidon Jewelers, 8 Glen Road Suite #18, West Lebanon, NH. Call or text us at 603-298-7600. Phone and chat assistance is available Monday–Saturday, 10 a.m.–5:30 p.m. ET. Our showroom is open Monday–Saturday, 10 a.m.–5:30 p.m. ET.

Customer Reviews